29 South Main Street, Oconomowoc, WI  53066


Monday - Tuesday  11:00 am - 8:00 pm

Wednesday-Saturday 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

Sunday - CLOSED 


Monday-  Closed 

Tuesday- Thursday - 10:30 - 8:00

​Friday - Saturday - 10:30 - 9:00

Sunday - 10:30 - 3:00

  • Instagram Social Icon
  • Facebook Clean

© 2018 Created By Strategx Solutions


Email us at - tom@bellagustomarket.com 
for any questions, concerns, parties or catering.




Our Family Favorites!

Grandpa’s Italian Sausage Sandwich

Our own special recipe served with marinara and hot or mild giardiniera and hot or mild sausage on a fresh baked roll.  



Grandma’s Meatball Sandwich

Homemade meatballs with provolone and marinara topped with parmesan cheese served on a sub roll.



Uncle Joey’s Italian Beef Sandwich

Our delicious Italian beef stacked on our fresh baked rolls and served with our homemade au jus, hot or mild giardiniera.



Tommy Jr’s Combo Sandwich

We bring Grandpa and Uncle Joey together to create Tommy Jr’s favorite! Hot or mild sausage, topped with Italian beef and hot or mild giardiniera.



Jeannie's Classic Italian Sandwich

Capicola, Italian ham, Genoa salami, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, topped with hot pepper relish, oregano oil, Sicilian sea salt, served on our 8 inch Hoagie roll.


Uncle Jimmy’s Italian Melt Panini

Italian panini bread with turkey, ham, provolone cheese, and pepperoncini rings finished with a balsamic mayo.  



Mel Mel’s Muffuletta Panini

Italian panini bread with salami, ham, mortadella, and mozzarella cheese finished with an olive tapenade.  


Nay Nay’s Caprese Panini

Italian panini bread with fresh mozzarella and tomatoes, basil pesto and finished with olive oil and balsamic glaze. $8.95   

Roasted Eggplant Panini 

Roasted eggplant, portabella mushrooms, onion, red pepper, burrata mozzarella cheese, pesto, and fresh spinach topped with creamy havarti cheese, served on Italian panini bread.


Kids Menu 

Ham And Cheese Sandwich 

Our badger ham and provolone cheese served panini style, with a side of house marinara. 


Grilled Cheese Sandwich 

Melted provolone, havarti, and mozzarella cheese served panini style, with a side of house marinara. 


Nutella Honey And Banana Sandwich 

Nutella, honey and banana served panini style. 


Mini Meatball Sandwich 

Two of our homemade meatballs, with fresh parmesan cheese and house marinara, on a fresh baked roll. 


Hot Dog 



Garden Salad 

Mixed greens with tomato, onion, banana peppers, homemade croutons and your choice of salad dressing.


Caesar Salad 

Fresh romaine lettuce, tossed with our house caesar dressing, homemade croutons, red onions and topped with freshly grated parmesan cheese.


Chef Salad 

Mixed greens with ham, turkey, egg, tomato, shredded mozzarella cheese and homemade croutons, with your choice of salad dressing.


Salad Add-Ons 

Chicken  --------    $3.50

Burrata  --------    $3.50

Anchovies ------    $2.00 

Bacon -------        $2.00 

Mushrooms ------ $1.50 

Salad Dressings 

Honey Mustard 

Balsamic Vinagrete 


Balsamic and oil 


Creamy Italian

Dinner Menu (Served from 5:00 to close) 

(All dinner's come with garlic bread and a side salad)

add to any entree Meatballs for $1.00 each or Hot or Mild Italian Sausage for $2.00 each.

Homemade Spaghetti 

Your choice of homemade meatballs or hot or mild Italian sausage, served over spaghetti noodles and topped with our house marinara and freshly grated parmesan-reggiano cheese.


Spicy Penne Ala Vodka

Our Housemade Vodka sauce, tossed with our penne pasta and topped with freshly grated asiago cheese. 


Pesto Capellini 

Roasted spring vegetables tossed in fresh pesto and served with capellini noodles. 


Chicken And Bacon Penne 

Grilled chicken and bacon with spinach, tomato and a garlic cream sauce served with penne pasta and topped with freshly grated asiago cheese. 


Italian Macaroni And Cheese

Shell noodles tossed in our homage three cheese sauce with crispy pancetta and prosciutto, topped with garlic breadcrumbs and then baked to perfection.


Kids Spaghetti And Meatballs 

Homemade meatballs served over spaghetti noodles with our house marinara and topped with freshly grated parmesan cheese. 


Spaghetti Aglio e Olio

A Traditional dish, our pasta mixed with extra virgin olive oil, fresh garlic, salt, pepper and a few crushed chilis


Italian Wedding Soup

Topped with our Fresh Shredded Parmesan.    

$4.95  (cup)  $6.95 (bowl)

Our Brick Oven Pizza 

12 in Cheese Pizza $12.00

16 in Cheese Pizza $15.00

Toppings are $2.00 each and choose from:

Meat Toppings-  Italian Sausage, Pepperoni, Meatballs, Pancetta, Prosciutto, Rotisserie Chicken, Italian Beef, Roast Beef and Ham

Veggie Toppings-Green Peppers, Onions, Black Olives, Green Olives, Garlic, Mushrooms, Portabello Mushrooms, Banana Peppers, Roma Tomatoes, Hot or Mild Giardiniera, Asparagus, Fresh Basil, Jalapenos, Spinach, Italian Roasted Tomatoes, Fresh Seasonal Greens, Artichoke Hearts, Pineapple and Egg Plant 

Signature Pizzas  

Dr Richards Deluxe- Our awesome pizza sauce, Italian Sausage, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Onions and our Kiss of Buffalo Milk Mozzarella Cheese

12 in $16.95      16 in $20.95

Nate's Meat Supreme - our  awesome pizza sauce, Italian sausage,pepperoni, ham, pancetta and our Kiss of Buffalo mozzarella

12 in $18.95      16 in $22.95

Uncle Sonny Veggie-  Our awesome pizza sauce, Green Peppers, Mushrooms, Onions, Black olives and our Kiss of Buffalo Milk Mozzarella Cheese

12 in $16.95      16 in $20.95

Shea's Italian Meatball Classic - Italian meatballs smothered with melted provolone and mozzarella with homemade marinara with fresh basil and fresh grated Parmesan

12 in $17.95      16 in $21.95

Ronnie Sanfilippo Spinach Classic - garlic EVOO (extra virgin olive oil)  topped with mozzarella, spinach, Italian sausage, mozzarella and drizzled with a bit more EVOO

12 in $16.95      16 in $20.95

Brother Phil’s Philly Cheesesteak - white american cheese topped with London broil, green peppers, onions and mozzarella

12 in $20.95      16 in $22.95

Aunt Sissy Margherita Pizza - fresh basil, fresh mozzarella, roma tomatoes and garlic EVOO

12 in $15.95      16 in $19.95

William's  BBQ -  rotisserie chicken breast & mozzarella sitting on top of sweet baby ray’s bbq sauce and topped with cheddar cheese

12 in $16.95      16 in $20.95

Mila's Asparagus and Prosciutto - garlic EVOO, goat cheese, asparagus, prosciutto, fresh seasonal greens and a drizzle of EVOO

12 in $20.95      16 in $23.95

Matty Pesto - fresh basil pesto topped with mushrooms, onions, Roma tomatoes and fresh grated Parmesan

12 in $17.95      16 in $21.95

Our Pinsa Romana

Pinsa Your Way-  comes with Our awesome pizza sauce and Kiss of Buffalo Milk Mozzarella for $10.95

All Pizza toppings listed above are available for $1.00 each

Specialty Pinsa's 

Pinsa Funghi- garlic EVOO topped with mozzarella, button & portabella mushrooms,roma tomatoes - drizzled with white truffle oil


Pinsa Tuscan Chicken- roasted tomatoes, onion, chicken ,fresh pesto, mozzarella & spinach


Pinsa Italian Beef- hot or mild giardiniera, Italian beef, mozzarella and more hot or mild giardiniera (ask for the au-jus on the side)


Pinsa Asparagus and Prosciutto - garlic EVOO, goat cheese, asparagus, prosciutto, fresh seasonal greens and a drizzle of EVOO


Pinsa Margherita- fresh basil, fresh mozzarella, roma tomatoes and garlic EVOO


Pinsa BBQ Chicken -  rotisserie chicken breast & mozzarella sitting on top of sweet baby ray’s bbq sauce and topped with cheddar cheese



Choose Your Favorite From our Great Selection of Cookies, Cannoli, Tiramisu & Cheesecakes! 

(Prices vary based on your choice of items)

Gift Certificates & Holiday Gift Baskets Available

Call for more details or visit us in the Deli!

Thank you all so much for visiting our deli and website.  

Come and enjoy!  We want you to feel like one of the family!